As the creator economy continues to grow, new CreatorIQ research suggests brands are moving beyond follower count when selecting creators. Suitability/brand fit is now the top consideration, followed by content performance, while follower count ranks last among the factors assessed. However, there is still a disconnect: follower numbers remain one of the strongest indicators of how much creators are paid.
The research also highlights the importance of authenticity. 42% of creators report tension between what their audience wants and what brands expect, rising among larger creators. Platform dynamics are evolving too: TikTok is the preferred platform for branded content among creators overall and is viewed as strongest for content performance, while Instagram is perceived as having greater potential for building a sustainable creator business.
What this means for us:
When recommending creators to clients, selection should move beyond reach and follower count towards relevance, audience fit and cultural influence. A smaller creator who naturally fits the brand and has credibility within a specific community may deliver more meaningful engagement than a larger creator chosen primarily for scale.
It also reinforces the need to treat creator and paid media as complementary. Creators can provide authenticity and culturally relevant content, while paid amplification can provide the additional reach required to scale successful creator content beyond their organic audiences
FAQs about creator selection and influencer marketing
-
Brands should assess a creator's audience demographics, content style, values and relevance to their campaign objectives. Previous collaborations and audience interactions can also provide useful context. CreatorIQ's State of Creator Marketing research ranked brand suitability as the most important creator-selection factor, ahead of content performance and follower count.
-
Brands should consider audience relevance, engagement, content performance and the results of previous collaborations. Depending on campaign objectives, useful measures may include reach, video views, engagement rates, website visits and conversions. Follower count can indicate potential audience size, but it does not establish whether a creator can reach the right people or achieve campaign objectives.
-
Brands can support authentic influencer partnerships by agreeing on clear campaign objectives while allowing creators flexibility in how they communicate. Content should fit the creator's usual style and audience expectations. CreatorIQ's 2026 research found that 42% of surveyed creators experienced tension between audience preferences and brand demands, highlighting the importance of balancing both.
-
Brands should consider the work involved, content deliverables, usage rights, exclusivity, production requirements and the creator's relevant audience. Follower count alone should not determine compensation. CreatorIQ's State of Creators 2026 found that creator earnings were more closely associated with follower numbers than engagement, despite brands placing greater importance on suitability and performance.
-
Brands should measure creator partnerships against their campaign objectives. Awareness campaigns may focus on reach, impressions and video views, while consideration and conversion campaigns can track engagement, website visits and sales. Using campaign-specific links or tracking codes where appropriate can help connect creator activity with measurable outcomes and inform future partnership decisions.